BofA downgrades Silicon Motion, slashes price target to $60: Time to sell or hold?

Silicon Motion Technology Corp. (NASDAQ: SIMO) is grappling with a significant blow as Bank of America (BofA) downgrades the stock from a Buy to an Underperform rating and slashes its price target from $90 to $60.

This drastic revision points to a potential downside of approximately 6.5% from current trading levels, raising questions about whether investors should sell or hold their positions.

Why the downgrade?

BofA’s downgrade stems from several key issues impacting Silicon Motion.

Analysts cited increased stock volatility, weakening demand in the commodity memory sector, and a less optimistic growth outlook.

The company’s limited exposure to high-growth areas like AI and enterprise SSD markets—dominated by rivals such as Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix—further influenced BofA’s decision.

Despite these challenges, Silicon Motion has been proactive in addressing market concerns and remains confident about achieving its full-year outlook, driven by its NAND OEM business.

Silicon Motion’s mixed Q2 earnings report

Silicon Motion’s second-quarter 2024 earnings report, released on August 1, presents a mixed picture.

The company narrowly beat Wall Street estimates with non-GAAP earnings per share (EPS) of $0.96, just $0.01 above the consensus.

Revenue reached $210.67 million, marking a 50% year-over-year (YoY) increase and slightly surpassing expectations by $1.67 million.

Performance varied across segments: SSD controller sales remained flat quarter-over-quarter (QoQ) but grew 25% to 30% YoY.

Conversely, eMMC and UFS controller sales surged by 190% to 195% YoY, while SSD solutions sales fell by 5% to 10% YoY, indicating some areas of weakness.

The SSD controller segment achieved its fifth consecutive quarter of revenue growth.

The company’s gross margin for Q2 2024 was 46%, reflecting strong pricing and cost management.

However, the operating margin, though improved from the previous year, remains a concern at 14.6%.

A significant cash position of $343.6 million offers a buffer against market volatility and potential for strategic investments or acquisitions.

Silicon Motion’s growth has been primarily driven by its leadership in NAND flash controllers, supported by over 3,900 patents.

Innovations such as the SM2322 single-chip controller for high-density portable SSDs and advancements in 3D NAND technology have positioned the company well in AI-enabled devices and gaming consoles.

However, the company’s low exposure to high-growth areas like AI and enterprise SSDs could limit expansion opportunities in the coming quarters.

Supply chain disruptions issues

Valuation-wise, Silicon Motion’s current P/E ratio (ttm) of 19.17 is below its historical average, suggesting moderate undervaluation.

Its PEG ratio (non-GAAP) of 0.91, significantly lower than the sector median, indicates potential upside if growth is sustained.

The downgrade and recent price volatility introduce uncertainty, making the stock a potential value trap if growth slows.

Key risks include supply chain disruptions, exacerbated by ongoing US-China trade tensions, and the need for continuous R&D investment to stay competitive in the rapidly evolving semiconductor industry.

With these fundamentals in mind, technical analysis will be crucial in determining whether the recent downgrade and mixed earnings results are already priced in or if further downside risks exist.

Downtrend reinforced

Silicon Motion’s stock rallied from below $30 to above $95 between mid-2020 and early 2022 but has remained in a downtrend since then. It seemed that this downtrend had come to an end when the stock bounced back from $50 to $85 between September 2023 and June this year.

Source: TradingView
However, the rapid fall it has gone through in the last two months and the 50-day moving average crossing below the 100-day moving average on daily charts has firmly established that the stock remains in a long-term downtrend.

Considering that investors who have a bullish outlook on the stock must not buy it at current levels. Any long positions must only be considered if the stock bounces back and gives a closing above its 50-day moving average.

Traders who are bearish on the stock can initiate short positions near $63 with a stop loss above $68, the recent swing high. If the bearish momentum prevails, the stock can again fall and find support near $50, where one can book profits.

The post BofA downgrades Silicon Motion, slashes price target to $60: Time to sell or hold? appeared first on Invezz